December 19, 2011
When Farmer Max bids his barnyard animals goodnight as he heads off to a Purim play, the animals gets moving on a plan: they’ll put on their own Purim play. Horse won’t say nay to his role as King Ahashuerus, and sheep is set to play bad Haman, until another animal sneaks into the barnyard, and Esther doesn’t duck an opportunity for barnyard heroism. Youngest readers who don’t know the story may be slightly confused, but those familiar with the holiday tale will enjoy its barnyard reimagining. The story by Terwilliger (Bubbe Isabella and the Sukkot Cake) economically endows its characters with distinctive personalities. Johansen Newman renders a Purim-lively setting crowded with animals in her full-bleed spreads. Ages 5–9.
January 15, 2012
The loud, chaotic celebration of Purim and its companion story is recreated in a farm-animal play that results in a surprising development. After Farmer Max leaves to attend a Purim play, the animals decide to stage their own version. Chicken offers to direct, orchestrating Horse as the King Ahashuerus, Duck as the blushing Queen Esther, bearded Goat as Mordecai, cows as the mooing noisemakers and geese as the audience. Casting a somewhat sensitive Sheep as the evil Haman requires some explanation from Chicken as she retells the holiday's story through her patient direction. "They aren't mooing at YOU...They're mooing at evil Haman." Still fretting over her role, Sheep retreats off stage to dress in, yes, her wolf's costume, while a new character, Fox, suddenly appears on the scene with real evil intentions. Confusion quickly moves to realization, with Duck's bravado leading a flurry of noisy animal antics to scare the fox away before Farmer Max returns with a basket of hamantaschen. Gouache cartoons of wide-eyed, long-lashed characters in muted browns, blacks and tans add enough charm to the required pathos of the text's circumvented telling for this menagerie's megillah. Enjoyable fare for youngsters who already have a concept of the holiday. (Picture books/religion. 5-7)
COPYRIGHT(2012) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
April 1, 2012
K-Gr 2-The story of how brave Queen Esther saved the Jewish people of Persia from wicked Haman's evil plot is often retold as a play during Purim. When Farmer Max leaves to go to the performance, the animals decide to put on their own production. Chicken appoints himself director and assigns the parts: Duck as Queen Esther, Goat as Mordechai, Horse as King Ahashuerus, and Sheep as Haman, with the cows as noisemakers and the geese as the members of the audience. But when Sheep has difficulty in his role as Haman, Goat takes him into the barn to find a costume to inspire him. Meanwhile, Fox shows up with his eyes on Duck. The animals all assume he is Sheep in a fox costume. When they realize their mistake, they band together to chase the interloper away. The detailed, expressive illustrations add to the animals' personalities, but the lengthy text is heavy on dialogue, making it difficult to distinguish among the characters. Not as accessible as Leone Adelson's The Mystery Bear: A Purim Story (Clarion, 2004), this offering will best be enjoyed by readers already familiar with the Purim story.-Rachel Kamin, North Suburban Synagogue Beth El, Highland Park, IL
Copyright 2012 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
July 1, 2012
When Farmer Max leaves for a Purim play, his barnyard animals have their own show. After director Chicken assigns the parts, the play begins, though an unexpected visit from a fox--a real-life evil Haman--threatens the production. This slight story, accompanied by spirited illustrations, does little to educate readers about Purim, though they'll get a sense of the characters' personalities.
(Copyright 2012 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)